Big news - $2.99 flat rate shipping! - now available

Ready-to-Drink Cocktail Review:
Cayman Jack Margarita


If I could only have one type of cocktail the rest of my life, it would be  margaritas! 

Especially skinny margaritas but either way, margs are my jam. So naturally the Cayman Jack margaritas caught my eye.

I picked up a six pack of these bottled margaritas at Target - along with a few extra rolls of shipping tape if you're following my Insta stories. I was drawn to the "realness" of the ingredients. This pre-made cocktail is made with 100% blue agave nectar, natural lime juice and real cane sugar. This isn't a brand I'd heard of but the packaging was pretty so of course that closed the deal for me. 

And I'm so happy it did. These babies are de-lish!  I'm telling you, you could buy these, pour them into margarita glasses and serve them to your guests as if you made them yourself after attending a fancy bartending school. Add a little cocktail flare with salt and a lime and no one would question you. Genius!
Cayman Jack margarita review by The Pursuit of Cocktails

 Here is official my score for the Cayman Jack Margarita:

Overall tastiness

Five Cocktail shakers

Winner winner chicken dinner! This was so close to a fresh, handmade marg that I'm call it *thisclose* to real thing. The only thing missing is a salted rim.

Three cocktail shakersOne shaker = not sweet at all // Five shakers = your teeth may curl

This margarita hit the sweet spot (no pun intended 😜) of being sweet but not too sweet. Plus it didn't have even a hint of that fake sugary taste you get with some pre-made cocktails.

Two cocktail shakers
One shaker = does this have booze? // Five shakers = Four Lokos

Officially this one rings in at 5.8% ABV. It has a little kick to it but it is tasty enough that you may want to keep count of your bottles lest you drink the whole 6-pack without realizing it. I hate when that happens! LOL

Would I buy this again?

For sure! Maybe as soon as tomorrow. I will be putting this drink into my regular rotation. It is the perfect cocktail to have on reserve for a spontaneous girls night or (maybe someday) a night cap after a great date. Does anyone say night cap anymore? Ready-to-drink cocktail review Cayman Jack margarita
I also did a little digging on Cayman Jack after being so pleasantly surprised with their margarita and was thrilled to find they have a mojito too. Consider me officially on the hunt for their mojitos. And of course, I'll let you know what I think of it right here. Stay tuned...

If you'd like to try this cocktail you can order it online from Drizly and have it shipped right to your door. Did you know you could have booze shipped to your home? Pretty awesome right?!?!?

Have you tried this drink? What did you think? I'd love to hear from you in the comments section. The more opinions the better! Let's have a drink together and share some girl talk.

Shop The Pursuit of Cocktails barware

We hope you enjoy our reviews. If you do decide to purchase these cocktails online using the links provided we may collect a small share of the sale. 

Five-star pre-made cocktails margarita Ready-to-drink cocktail review tequila cocktails

← Older Post Newer Post →


  • @tara I will definitely check out the Mike’s version. Thanks for the tip! I’m on a mission to try all of the margaritas and all of the moscow mules to find the best ones for us!

    Jaime Fowler on
  • I need to try these, thank you for your review! I have been on the hunt for a “real” tasting margarita in a bottle. Unfortunately the one I found that is a must try isn’t sold anywhere near me so I only get when on vacation. If you haven’t tried them yet check out Mikes Hard Classic Margarita, you won’t be disappointed!
    Thanks again for your review!

    Tara on
  • @christina – You should definitely pick it up next time you’re there. It is soooo good!

    Jaime on
  • I was just at Total Wine and saw this – now I wish I would have bought it! Yum!

    Christina on

Leave a comment