After trying tons of canned, bottled, and pre-made margaritas over the years, I've decided to celebrate this festive holiday by sharing my favorites with you. So grab your shopping list and take notes. Here are my favorite ready-to-drink margaritas I've tried so far.
Best Overall: Cayman Jack Margarita
This marg from Cayman Jack was one of the very first ready-to-drink cocktails I tried and reviewed. I was shocked at how good it was - which only spurred me to try more pre-made cocktails. If only they were all as good as the Cayman Jack margarita, our lives would be much tastier.
Cayman Jack is at the very top of the list for us for both "best margarita" AND "best bottled cocktail." If you haven't tried one yet you really should.
My favorite fancy margaritas - aka unique flavors:
Austin Cocktails Bergamot Orange Margarita
This margarita from the Austin Cocktails line wins are vote for fancy, non-traditional margarita. It is rich with orange flavor (not traditionally found in a margarita) and has a booze kick without a ton of sugar that some margaritas have.
If you are looking for an elevated margarita then definitely check this one out.
Crafthouse Cocktails Smoky Margarita
Discovering the Crafthouse Cocktails has been one of my favorite experiences as a cocktail blogger. This full line is amazing and their Smoky Margarita is perfection.
Not only is the Crafthouse Cocktails Smoky amazing - it is also available in single serve aluminum bottles, wine sized glass bottles, and the game changing BOX OF COCKTAILS that has 15 margaritas worth of goodness tucked inside. And if there is a margarita that is worthy of having a box, it's this one!!
While this might not be a high brow canned cocktail, it certainly has it's place on my list of favorite margaritas.
I love how there are so many Rita flavors and their accessibility is top notch. You can find these babies almost anywhere. Heck you can even get them in a multi-pack.
Don't over look these for a fun party or camping addition. They might not be the fanciest margarita on our list but they are super tasty and fun.
My favorite traditional margaritas:
Post Meridiem Margarita
Don't let the size of this can fool you, there is a strong, super tasty margarita waiting for you inside. And this one has real lime juice which might not seem like that big a deal but I promise you it's magic. The lime juice sets this one apart from the pack. it is so good. I want another can of it right now just thinking about it!
One more thing important thing to note about this one is that it is boozy af. This can is small because the cocktail inside is 27.5% ABV - just like a margarita should be in my book.
Cutwater Lime Margarita
Cutwater makes a mean marg. Their Lime Margarita doesn't get as much attention as it should in our opinion.
I was super surprised how accurate this canned cocktail was was for a bar quality margarita. I've tried a lot of ready-to-drink margs since I first tried this one several years ago but I still think of it often and I don't hesitate to pick it up again when I'm at the store. The Cutwater Spirit canned cocktails are always a solid choice.
10 Barrel Brewing Classic Margarita
If there was a ready-to-drink margarita award for best can design, this one would win hands down for me. I love how colorful and festive this can is. But most importantly, it is not just a pretty face. There is a really solid, super traditional margarita inside that can.
I originally described this canned margarita as reliable and I'm going to stand by that description. This marg is like an old friend. You know what to expect from it and it won't let you down.
And one more margarita tip because I don't want any other cocktail lovers to suffer...
Avoid at all costs: The Skinnygirl Margarita
I still shutter a little bit thinking about this one. It was just bad. Like really bad. The flavor was flat. The sweetness was all wrong with an overwhelming fake sweet taste to it. And it was booze in a cheap drunk kind of way that left her with a headache before she'd even finished my drink.
If you are going to a party at someone's house you don't like and you are going to just drop in and leave - then maybe consider taking this margarita as your hostess gift. But don't drink it yourself under any circumstances!
We are always trying new margaritas. In fact we try a new ready-to-drink cocktail every Friday. Come back each week for a fresh cocktail review or stay tuned into our margarita reviews exclusively using the link below.
FULL LIST OF READY-TO-DRINK MARGARITA REVIEWS HERE: https://www.thepursuitofcocktails.com/blogs/the-pursuit-of-cocktails/tagged/margarita
Shop our Margarita Swizzly Sticks™
Note: We hope you enjoy our reviews. If you do decide to purchase these cocktails online using the links provided we may collect a small share of the sale.